Opens in a new tab
deuteronomy 27:15

An Open Declaration Against Secret Sin (Deuteronomy 27:15)

Idolatry. Land theft. Incest. Injustice. What do all of those things have in common?

Surprisingly, they’re all part of the same grouping of laws that the people bound themselves to uphold in Deuteronomy 27. With the Levites at the center, in a valley between two mountains that had six tribes on each, the nation agreed not to commit these very specific sins.

But why these sins? And why not more along with them?

Why, for instance, does God demand the people agree not to lie with his father’s wife, but not a woman with her mother’s husband (Deuteronomy 27:20)?

Why are they told not to take a bribe to strike down an innocent person (Deuteronomy 27:25)? Does that mean they can take bribes for other reasons?

There is virtually no rhyme or reason why these specific sins are mentioned explicitly here. As far as I understand it, no explanation is satisfactory.

However, there is one repeating element that seems to bind them all together: secrecy.

The Text seems to hint at this. In two places (Deuteronomy 27:15 and 24), the idea of doing something in secret is mentioned. Conveniently, they’re at the beginning and end of these verses, which means that they could also refer to the interior as well.

And when you look at these verses, “secret sins” does seem to be the theme.

Moving a neighbor’s boundary mark would most likely happen when nobody else was around (Deuteronomy 27:17). You move it inch by inch, a little at a time, until, eventually, you’ve taken a chunk of their land inheritance.

The same applies to misleading a blind person (Deuteronomy 27:18). Unless there is someone else nearby, that blind person will never know where you’re actually taking them because, obviously, they’re blind.

Even the sexual sins could happen in secret. A man taking his father’s wife (27:20) or his sister (27:22) while his dad is working in the field wouldn’t be obvious. Nor would having sex with an animal (27:21). All three could happen—and indeed, would most likely happen—in as much secrecy as possible.

If this is the one thread binding them all together, then it appears that what God is holding these people to are everyday acts of justice that can’t always be mandated by the courts (Remember: You need at least two witnesses to establish fact, according to Deuteronomy 19:15).

No one may know about these sins except for God, but that doesn’t mean they won’t impact the nation.

It’s telling that God has the nation of Israel pronounce these curses together. They will all stand near each other and agree not to “distort the justice due an alien,” among others.

And if they held themselves to it, everything would be fine.

The key word in that sentence, though, is “if.”